Skip to content


What would you do if your twin—a piano prodigy—were murdered?


Rumors swirl that you are the killer, and then you start receiving threatening emails...


This is exactly what happens to seventeen-year old Clara Seibert.


About the Author

I’m addicted to reading and writing young adult novels—not to mention chocolate, romance, and my husband’s cooking. Spoiler Alert about my bio: It’s not about how I always knew I wanted to be a writer. Instead…

About the Book

Clara Seibert ghostwrites an advice column. She’s funny, feisty, and cares deeply, but her own problems threaten to overwhelm her. With a murdered twin sister, threatening emails and a stalker in pursuit, Clara begins her own investigation.

Quotes of Praise

“Gripping and relevant, It Should Have Been You captivates readers with its authentic voice and well-crafted mystery. At once innocent and wise, Clara is a protagonist worth rooting for as she searches for the truth about her sister’s death. Important issues like domestic abuse and survivor’s guilt are handled with a well-tuned sensitivity that is never dogmatic or depressing. A fast-paced, sometimes harrowing, ultimately satisfying story you won’t forget.”
—Jessica Freely, author of All the Colors of Love

“From the first sentence, through all of the twists and turns to the surprising ending, this book will hold you in its grasp and not let go.”
—V.M. Burns, author of Bookmarked for Murder

It Should Have Been You takes readers on a compelling psychological journey of obsession and its effects. Readers will benefit from advice-columnist Clara’s girl-power attitude as they turn the pages to uncover the real villain. Issues of identity, fame, and artistic talent add depth to a compulsively readable mystery. Lynn Slaughter has written a winner!
—Lee Tobin McClain, bestselling author of Low Country Dreams & Sizzle

Latest Post

No Bah Humbug for Me! Why I Love the Holidays

I often hear less than enthusiastic comments about this time of year: “I can’t wait for the holidays to be over!” “This is so stressful.” “There’s always so much to do and not enough time.” Well, yeah. The to-do list I made this morning has a mere 24 items on it. But I love the…

Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid email address.
Something went wrong. Please check your entries and try again.

In the Works

While investigating the disappearance of her beloved music teacher, Leisha falls hard for a boy she wasn’t supposed to love. But time for romance may be running out—because as Leisha draws closer to finding her teacher, she puts her own life in grave danger.

Latest News & Events

Saturday, November 16, 2019: Will participate in panel, “Feeding the Fire: Building a Vibrant Writing Life” with writers Mary Lou Northern and Ellen Birkett Morris at the Writer’s Block Festival at Spalding University in Louisville.

Thrilled to announce that my short story, "Missed Cue," will appear in Malice Domestic's 2020 anthology, MURDER MOST THEATRICAL.

Also by Lynn

WHILE I DANCED was the “Pick of the Month” for Dance Spirit magazine and was a 2015 finalist for the EPIC competition in the young readers’ category.