Where Do Characters Come From? Guest Essay by Mystery Author Skye Alexander

I’m so delighted to welcome Skye Alexander to my blog today whose second novel in her Lizzie Crane cozy mystery series, What the Walls Know, was just published by Level Best Books. In her guest essay, Skye thoughtfully discusses the centrality of characters in our work and our lives as writers. Following her essay, you can read brief descriptions of What the Walls Know and the first book in her Lizzy Crane series, Never Try to Catch a Falling Knife, as well as Skye’s bio.

Where Do Characters Come From?

by Skye Alexander

Do writers create our characters or do our characters find us? Are they the children of our minds or do they exist independent of us, somewhere in the ethers, like spirits searching for host mothers to give them life on earth? When the time is right, when they spot an opportunity, do characters slip into our consciousness and reveal themselves to us? Even after decades of writing, I still don’t know the answer to this question.

Writers have intense and intimate connections with our characters. For many of us, the characters in our books are every bit as real as the flesh-and-blood people we interact with on a daily basis. We know more about them than we know about our spouses, our siblings, our friends. We think about them even when we’re not actually writing. Our characters talk to us when we’re taking a shower, walking in a park, shopping for groceries, and trying to sleep. They ride along with us when we’re commuting to work. They offer advice on cooking or fashion or how to handle our kids––whether or not we asked for it. They latch onto us and won’t let go. They become our constant companions (and yes, we even have a certain fondness for the bad guys). Being a writer gives us license to have imaginary friends, so if you notice us talking to ourselves, we’re not nuts. We’re simply having a conversation with our BFFs or testing out a bit of dialogue.

People often ask me where my characters come from. Occasionally, a reader insists he or she is someone I’ve written about in one of my books. I refer you folks to the disclaimer at the beginning of each novel that says something to the effect of: “This is a work of fiction. Except in the case of historic fact, any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.”                 

That doesn’t mean we writers won’t appropriate a particular tidbit we find intriguing, such as your $3,000 custom-made cowboy boots, or that port-wine birthmark in the shape of New Jersey on your thigh, or your habit of clapping your hands three times and circling widdershins before entering your mother-in-law’s house. Warning: Writers are thieves, so don’t do or tell us anything really cool unless you’re okay with it appearing in print. But no, we don’t usually reproduce the ordinary people we know in our novels––unless we’re trying to reap vengeance, but that’s another story.

Fictional characters want to tell their tales and make their marks in the literary world. Sometimes I give a character a bit part and she pushes her way into a starring role. Writers tend to fall in love with our characters. We don’t want to say goodbye, so we write a series. Agatha Christie’s Detective Hercule Poirot starred in thirty-three novels, fifty-nine short stories, and one full-length play. Naturally, the protagonist appears in every book in the series, but often subordinate or even minor characters turn up again and again, especially if the stories occur in a particular place, such as Louise Penny’s fictional town Three Pines.

In my Lizzie Crane mystery series, which is set in the mid-1920s, I invite a few historical figures to play cameos. This gives a period feeling to the novels, adds a splash of color, and in some cases furthers the plot. However, these real-life people are presented in a fictitious manner. The artist Edward Hopper comes to a party in the third book in my series (The Goddess of Shipwrecked Sailors, scheduled for release in August 2023). In the fourth novel (Running in the Shadows), Charles Lindbergh performs a daredevil aerial show. In my books, these famous folks do things they really did––yes, Lindbergh was a barnstorming stunt pilot before he flew across the Atlantic and into history books. But, of course, these famous folks never actually met my characters (at least, not to my knowledge).

Characters drive stories, they’re not just along for the ride. If we don’t connect with the characters in a novel, we probably won’t read more than a couple chapters. If we really, really like them, we’ll follow them wherever they go. They take us to places and time periods we might never know about otherwise. They present us with ideas and situations we might never have considered before. They teach us about courage, compassion, patience, strength, humility, tragedy, and triumph. They help us understand ourselves and the people we know better. By sharing their journeys with us, characters in books reveal to us the vastness of the human experience with all its complexity, richness, and magic.

About What the Walls Know:

It’s October 1925 in Gloucester, Massachusetts. When jazz singer Lizzie Crane accepts an invitation to perform at a Halloween party in a creepy castle, she thinks witches, wizards, ghosts, and fortune-tellers are her only worries—until a woman dies of a suspicious heroin overdose and Lizzie becomes a murder suspect, or maybe the next victim.

About Never Try to Catch a Falling Star:

In August of 1925, jazz singer Lizzie Crane and her troupe land a plum job: a week-long engagement celebration for the daughter of a wealthy industrialist to a Russian count. But before Lizzie can enjoy her good luck, she finds the group’s saxophonist stabbed to death. Police suspect her and her musician friends and place them under house arrest. As Lizzie delves into her slain colleague’s mysterious past, she discovers secrets worth killing for and risks her own life in the process.


Skye Alexander is the author of nearly 50 fiction and nonfiction books. Her stories have been published in anthologies internationally and her work has been translated into more than a dozen languages. The first novel in her Lizzie Crane mystery series, Never Try to Catch a Falling Knife, was published by Level Best Books in August 2021. The second, What the Walls Know, was released in November 2022, and she’s currently working on the fifth one. Visit her website www.skyealexander.com.


  1. Skye Alexander on December 15, 2022 at 11:05 am

    Thanks so much, Lynn, for letting me share my thoughts with your readers.

  2. Mike Bradley on December 15, 2022 at 11:14 am

    Well written, Skye and so true!

  3. George Cramer on December 15, 2022 at 8:05 pm

    Skye, your description of the interaction between writers and their characters was spot on. I find myself talking to my characters at the oddest times such as when I should be listening to my wonderful wife, shopping, driving, and often when I wake at 1:00 a.m. Thanks for sharing with us.

    • Skye Alexander on May 18, 2023 at 9:21 pm

      They do have a tendency to take over the conversation, but I usually enjoy chatting with them as I would with my other friends. Thanks for commenting.

    • Skye Alexander on May 18, 2023 at 9:25 pm

      Thanks so much George. I’ve found that once I give them space to talk they won’t shut up 😊

  4. Kassandra Lamb on December 15, 2022 at 11:14 pm

    All so true, Skye!

    I’ve had minor or secondary characters write bigger parts for themselves quite often.

Leave a Comment